I came across this on HFBoards. I guess
Julie "The Cat" Gaffney Hannu Toivonen and Peter Budaj squared off in a game between the P-Bruins and the Hersey Bears on November 12, 2004. Apparently, the officials sent both teams to the dressing rooms with over 4 minutes remaining in the second period following a brawl. As the two teams were filing off the ice, the two mediocre puckstoppers met up at center ice and traded knuckles. Budaj clearly got the win in this one. According to Drop Your Gloves Budaj threw 21 punches and landed 7, while Toivonen managed to throw 7 (2 even landed!).